City of Houston Archaeological and Historical Commission met Sept. 12

Webp 1
Tarsha Jackson Council Member - District B | City of Houston

City of Houston Archaeological and Historical Commission met Sept. 12.

Here are the minutes provided by the commission:

Call to Order at 2:32 PM by David Bucek, Chair

Commissioners 

Quorum – Present / Absent

David Bucek, Chair

Present left at 6:01

Beth Wiedower Jackson, Vice Chair

Present during Item A at 2:37, left at 4:30

Shantel Blakely

Present

John Cosgrove, Acting Chair

Present

Steven Curry

Absent

Tanya Debose

Present during Item B.15 at 4:44, left at 5:38

Ashley Jones

Present

Ben Koush

Present

Stephen McNiel

Absent

Rhonda Sepulveda

Absent

Charles Stava

Present, left at 6:20

Dominic Yap

Present

Nicole Broussard, Acting Secretary

Present

CHAIR’S REPORT – David Bucek

DIRECTOR’S REPORT – Nicole Broussard, Acting Secretary and Deputy Assistant Director of the Houston Planning and Development Department.

MAYOR LIAISON’S REPORT – None

CONSIDERATION OF AUGUST 15, 2024 HAHC MEETING MINUTES 

Commission action: Approved.

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Yap Abstaining: None

A. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A PROTECTED LANDMARK DESIGNATION APPLICATION FOR JOHN S. STEWART HOUSE AT 109 STRATFORD ST, HOUSTON, TX 77006. 

Staff recommendation: Approve and forward the application to City Council for Landmark Designation.

Commission action: Approved and forwarded the application to City Council. Speaker(s): Lily Aguillard – applicant, available for questions

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Stava Abstaining: None

HAHC 1 of 5 

B. CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATIONS FOR CONSENT AGENDA: 

Address 

Application Type 

Historic District/PLM/LM

Staff Recommendation

1

525 Woodland St

Alteration – Addition

Woodland Heights

Approval w/ Cond

2

717 E 5th ½ St

New Construction – Single Family Residential

Freeland

Approval

3

1711 Shearn St

Alteration – Addition

High First Ward

Approval w/Cond

4

1508 Rutland St

Alteration – Addition

Houston Heights West

Approval w/Cond

5

1508 Rutland St

New Construction – Garage

Houston Heights West

Approval

6

1131 Allston St

Alteration – Addition

Houston Heights West

Denial

7

1131 Allston St

New Construction – Garage

Houston Heights West

Denial

8

1987 W Gray St

Alteration – Sign

LM: River Oaks Theatre and Shopping Center

Approval

9

HRI HHA Freedmen Town Houses

Alteration – Siding

Freedmen’s Town

Deferral

10

1019 Columbia St

Alteration – Addition

Houston Heights South

Denial COR Changed to Approval

11

1019 Columbia St

New Construction – Garage

Houston Heights South

Approval

12

1011 W Cottage St

Alteration – Addition

Norhill

Approval

13

902 Commerce St

Alteration – Sign

Main Street Market Square

Approval w/Cond

14

908 Congress St

Alteration – Sign

Main Street Market Square

Approval

15

3423 White Oak

Alteration

Heights South

Defer

16

627 Highland St

Alteration – Addition

Woodland Heights

Deferral

17

927 W Cottage St

Alteration – Front Elevation

Norhill

Deferral

18

3711 Audubon Pl

Alteration – Windows

Audubon Place

Denial. COR.

19

3708 Audubon Pl

Alteration – Windows

Audubon Place

Denial. COR.

20

1221 Columbia St

New Construction – Garage

Houston Heights East

Approve

21

528 Harvard St

Alteration – Addition

Houston Heights South

Approve

22

1110 Jerome

New Construction

Norhill

Denial

23

643 Cortlandt

New Construction Garage

Heights South

Approval

24

914 Main St

Alteration

LM

Approval

Staff recommendation: Approve recommendations for Items B. 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 20, 23, and 24, with the accepted change from to Item 10, from Denial to Approval. Commission action: Accepted staff recommendations for all items listed above including changes, Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) and Certificates of Remediation (COR). Speaker(s): None

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Carried

Second: Stava Abstaining: Bucek

B1. 525 WOODLAND STREET

Staff recommendation: Approval with conditions; Historic windows to be relocated shall be installed in the contributing historic structure. The historic window at the proposed rear left elevation shall not be installed in the addition. Install a new inset and recessed window in this location.

Commission action: Approved as submitted.

Speaker(s): Sam Gianukos

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Wiedower Jackson Opposed: None

B3. 1711 SHEARN STRET

Staff recommendation: Approval with conditions; the applicant and agent work with staff to determine a solution for the bathroom window at the west elevation.

Commission action: Accepts staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): David Jefferis – applicant

Motion: Wiedower Jackson Vote: Unanimous

Second: Cosgrove Opposed: None

ITEMS B 6 AND 7 WERE TAKEN TOGETHER AT THIS TIME. 

B6. 1131 ALLSTON STREET

Staff recommendation: Denial, does not satisfy criteria 10 and Houston Heights Design Guidelines.

B7. 1131 ALLSTON STREET

Staff recommendation: Denial, does not satisfy criteria 3 and doesn’t meet Houston Heights Historic District Measurable Standards.

Commission action for both B.6 and B.7: Deferred.

Speaker(s): Jose Cordova – applicant, Denn Ath, T. Laoboonravg, Justin Patterson Motion: Koush Vote: Unanimous

Second: Yap Abstaining: None

B12. 1011 W COTTAGE STREET

Staff recommendation: Approval.

Commission action: Accepts staff recommendation for approval.

Speaker(s): Amanda Reynolds, Virgina Kelsey, Emilo Consulate

Motion: Yap Vote: Unanimous

Second: Cosgrove Abstaining: None

B15. 3423 WHITE OAK

Staff recommendation: Defer.

Commission action: Deferred, applicant needs to work with staff for further recommendations. Speaker(s): Greg Thompson, Shawn Guess – applicant, Matt Stewart, Rob Mister Motion: Blakely Vote: Unanimous

Second: Cosgrove Abstaining: None

B16. 627 HIGHLAND STREET

Staff recommendation: Defer.

Commission action: Accepts staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): Michael Gonzales, Chad Hammon

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Yap Abstaining: None

B21. 528 HARVARD STREET

Staff recommendation: Approve.

Commission action: Accepts staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): Sam Gianukos – applicant

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Blakely Abstaining: None

B22. 1110 JEROME

Staff recommendation: Denial, does not satisfy criteria – 2,3,4. If approve, should be conditional upon replat.

Commission action: Approved as submitted subject to replat.

Speaker(s): JD Bartell – applicant, Amanda Reynolds, Virgina Kelsey

Motion: Koush Vote: Unanimous

Second: Cosgrove Abstaining: None

C. CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON THE RECLASSIFICATION OF 3109 MORRISON ST IN WOODLAND HEIGHTS HISTORIC DISTRICT 

Staff recommendation: Recommend to City Council for reclassification to non-contributing. Commission action: Denied.

Speaker(s): Nat Smith – applicant

Motion: Yap Vote: Carried

Second: Koush Opposed: Jones, Blakely

D. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC – 

Harp Singh: wanted to introduce himself to the commission and mentioned his applications he submitted.

Molly Hardling: she did not understand the process of HAHC and wanted to know the action on her property, Acting Chair directed staff to assist her on the next steps.

E. COMMENTS FROM THE HAHC – None

F. HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER’S REPORT – OSW DESIGN GUIDELINES IN PROGRESS – None

ADJOURNMENT 

There being no further business brought before the Commission, Acting Chair John Cosgrove adjourned the meeting at 6:21 PM.

https://www.houstontx.gov/planning/Commissions/hahc20241010/10-10-2024_HAHC_%20AGENDA_FOR_POSTING_Merged_With_Minutes.pdf

Related