City of Houston Archaeological and Historical Commission met June 29

City of Houston Archaeological and Historical Commission met June 29.

Here are the minutes provided by the commission:

Called to order at 2:33 PM by David Bucek, Chair

Commissioners

Quorum – Present / Remote / Absent

David Bucek, Chair

Present

Beth Wiedower Jackson, Vice Chair

Present Remote at 2:44 during item A

Ann Collum

Present and left at 5:59 during item G

John Cosgrove

Present

Steven Curry

Present

Tanya Debose

Present Remote

Ashley Elizabeth Jones

Present at 2:40 during item A

Ben Koush

Present

Stephen McNiel

Present

Rhonda Sepulveda

Absent

Charles Stava

Present Remote

Dominic Yap

Present

Jennifer Ostlind, Executive Secretary

Present

Legal Department – Alice Adam – Present

Chair’s Report – NONE

Director’s Report - Jennifer Ostlind, Deputy Director, Planning and Development Department

Mayor’s Liaison Report – NONE

APPROVAL OF MINUTES

Consideration of May 18, 2023 HAHC Training and HAHC Meeting Minutes

Commission Action: Minutes presented were approved

Motion: McNiel Vote: Unanimous

Second: Stava Abstaining: None

CHAIR DAVID BUCEK OPENED AND CLOSED THE PUBLIC HEARING FOR ITEMS A, B, C AND D.

A. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION AN AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER 33, ARTICLE VII, DIVISION 5 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES, ADDING A NEW SECTION 33-269 TO PROVIDE AN EXEMPTION TO THE CITY OF HOUSTON SIGN CODE TO ALLOW ROOFTOP SIGNS ON PROTECTED LANDMARK BUILDINGS AND ESTABLISHING STANDARDS. (ROMAN MCALLEN, PRESERVATION OFFICER)

Staff recommendation: Approve the item per staff report and forward to City Council. Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): None

Motion: Wiedower Jackson Vote: Unanimous

Second: McNiel Abstaining: None

B. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A PROTECTED LANDMARK DESIGNATION APPLICATION FOR OLIVEWOOD CEMETERY AT 1300 COURT STREET, HOUSTON, TX 77007. (TAYLOR VALLEY, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approve the item per staff report and forward to City Council. Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): Paul Jennings, Jasmine Lee, Margo Williams – supportive

Motion: Yap Vote: Unanimous

Second: Debose Abstaining: None

C. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A PROTECTED LANDMARK DESIGNATION APPLICATION FOR THREE OAKS, MR. & MRS. H. ARCH. SPRADLEY HOUSE AT 2201 ALBANS ROAD, HOUSTON, TX 77005. (YASMIN ARSLAN, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approve the item per staff report and forward to City Council. Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): Emily Ardoin with Preservation Houston, applicant – supportive

Motion: McNiel Vote: Unanimous

Second: Cosgrove Abstaining: None

D. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON A PROTECTED LANDMARK DESIGNATION APPLICATION FOR THE GOODMAN HOUSE AT 426 WESTMORELAND ST, HOUSTON, TX 77006. (CHARLES SADLER, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approve the item per staff report and forward to City Council. Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation.

Speaker(s): Hannah Curry with SWCA, applicant – supportive

Motion: Cosgroveh Vote: Unanimous

Second: Debose Abstaining: None

E. CONSIDERATION OF AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATIONS FOR CONSENT AGENDA: (ROMAN MCALLEN)

#

Address

Application Type

Historic District

Staff

Recommendation

1

1113 Tulane St

Demolition

Houston Heights West

No recommendation

2

717 Arlington St

Alteration - Addition

Houston Heights South

Approval with

Conditions

3

904 Arlington St

Alteration – Siding,

Windows

Houston Heights South

Denial. Issuance of COR

4

4104 Greeley St

Alteration – Siding, Porch or Balcony, Roof

First Montrose Commons

Denial. Issuance of COR

5

1117 Peddie St

New Construction – Single Family Residential

Norhill

Withdrawn

by Applicant

6

1131 E 11th St

Alteration – Siding

Norhill

Denial. Issuance of COR

7

1802 Harvard St

Alteration – Siding,

Windows

Houston Heights East

Approval with

Conditions

8

1208 Cortlandt St

New Construction – Garage

Houston Heights East

Defet

9

527 Frasier St

Alteration – Addition,

Windows, Porch

Freeland

Denial. Issuance of COR

10

611 W 22nd St

Alteration – Doors, Windows

LM: Oriental Textile Mill

Approval

11

2012 W Gray St

Alteration – Sign

LM: River Oaks Theater and Shopping Center

Approval

12

725 W Cottage St

Alteration – Addition

Norhill

Approval

13

122 E 31st ½ St

New Construction – SFR

Starkweather

Approval with

Conditions

14

124 E 31st ½ St

New Construction – SFR

Starkweather

Approval with

Conditions

Commission Action: Accepted staff recommendations for Items E. 3, 4, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 14 Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) and Certificates of Remediation (COR).

Speaker(s): None

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Jones Abstaining: None

ITEMS REMOVED FOR SEPARATE CONSIDERATION: E – 1, 2, 6, 7 AND 12.

E.1. 1113 TULANE ST., HOUSTON HEIGHTS WEST (YASMIN ARSLAN, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: No recommendation.

Commission action: Approve partial demolition with the conditions that only the rear addition may be removed, ending at original house corner; keep salvageable historic material; and with new addition subject to staff approval.

Speaker(s): Pete Stockton, Sr. Inspector, Houston Public Works

Toufic and Angela Halabi, applicants – supportive; Jan Rynda Greer – undecided

Motion: Koush Vote: Carried

Second: Stava Opposed: McNiel

E.2. 717 ARLINGTON ST., HOUSTON HEIGHTS SOUTH (YASMIN ARSLAN, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approval with conditions.

Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation and report.

Speaker(s): None

Motion: Yap Vote: Unanimous

Second: Stava Abstaining: None

E.6. 1131 E 11TH ST., NORHILL (TAYLOR VALLEY, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Denial, Issuance of COR with the condition of paint removal. Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation and report.

Speaker(s): Ann Thomas, applicant – position not known

Motion: McNiel Vote: Unanimous

Second: Koush Abstaining: None

E.7. 1802 HARVARD ST., HOUSTON HEIGHTS EAST (TAYLOR VALLEY, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approval with conditions.

Commission action: Approved per applicant’s request, with window allowed to be moved from side to front; and staff to approve final plans.

Speaker(s): Jan Rynda Greer, applicant - supportive

Motion: Cosgrove Vote: Unanimous

Second: Collum Abstaining: None

E.12. 725 W COTTAGE ST., NORHILL (JASON LILENTHAL, STAFF)

Staff recommendation: Approval.

Commission action: Approved per staff recommendation and report.

Speaker(s): Lawrence Febo, Virginia Kelsey - opposed

Mollie LeBlanc, Thomas LeBlanc, applicant – supportive

Motion: McNiel Vote: Carried

Second: Curry Opposed: Collum, Yap, Stava

F. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC

Speaker: Dominic Yap – Taxes and Appraisal District valuations (HCAD)

G. COMMENTS FROM THE HAHC

Commissioners McNiel, Koush – How to address repeat offenders in historic neighborhoods.

H. HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER’S REPORT

Roman McAllen mentioned a possible CAMP training grant, and a design guideline draft pending for September.

I. ADJOURNMENT

There being no further business brought before the Commission, Chair David Bucek adjourned the meeting at 6:04 PM.

https://www.houstontx.gov/planning/Commissions/minutes_hahc23/062923-HAHCMinutesACTION.pdf